New York, New York: Yankees Win Two Of Three After Rangers Fail To Make Early Lead Stand Up

D-tails: (Yankees 8, Rangers 6)
Boxscore, Standings, Depot live game blog
• Radio voice Eric Nadel to miss time with torn retina; Nadel’s email

NEW YORK - It is entirely possibly the ball New York outfielder Melky Cabrera hit for a game-changing home run Thursday was one of those that got caught in the freakish jet stream that has made new Yankee Stadium a home run haven.

Yeah, and like that meant a lot to C.J. Wilson, who authored the eighth-inning changeup that became the difference in an 8-6 Yankees win over the Rangers.

“It was a bad pitch,” Wilson said, perched atop the chair at his locker. “The stadium doesn’t matter. My main goal was to make a good pitch and I didn’t make one.”

Less than 24 hours after he dazzled and overwhelmed Alex Rodriguez in a key eighth-inning situation, Wilson couldn’t repeat the feat against the bottom half of the Yankees lineup.

Called on with the score tied at six, Wilson immediately walked No. 5 hitter Robinson Cano on a full-count pitch, then got Hideki Matsui on a fly ball to center field. He had the count at 1-and-1 on Cabrera when he tried to throw a changeup down and in. He got the “in” part right, but left too much of the pitch in the hitting zone and Cabrera turned on it. It just cleared the glove of leaping LF David Murphy to change the game. Murphy had timed the leap perfectly and extended well above the left field wall, but still came away with only the same empty feeling that followed the Rangers out of Yankee Stadium.

The Rangers had a chance to make a statement in the series and missed doing so by the same tiny distance that separated Murphy’s glove from a spectacular catch on the home run ball.

“It would have meant a lot to win this game and this series,” Murphy said. “It would have made for really good morale going into Boston. But it’s still early June and we can’t dwell on one loss or one series too much. Today hurts, but tomorrow is a new day. We can’t afford to let one day carry over into another.”

The Rangers had tied the series at a game apiece on Wednesday night when starter Scott Feldman and Wilson teamed up to flummox Rodriguez in three crucial situations.

And they began Thursday right where they left off Wednesday. They built a 5-1 lead and starter Brandon McCarthy seemed to be heading towards his third consecutive impressive win. And then, all the crucial moments – and momentum – seemed to go in the opposite direction.

On Wednesday, for example, when starter Scott Feldman appeared headed for trouble, a big inning was avoided when a Yankee slugger squibbed a ball down third base line and Michael Young turned it into huge double play. On Thursday, after McCarthy allowed hits to the bottom two hitters in the Yankees lineup to start the fifth, he followed it with consecutive walks to Johnny Damon and Nick Swisher (the latter forcing in a run).

Then, with the bases loaded, Mark Teixeira hit a similar ball to the one Young turned into a double play on Wednesday. Perhaps it was hit a bit harder and Young was playing a little deeper with a three-run lead. So when he went to field the ball – having no shot at a double play – it spun away from him and turned into a game-tying three-run double.

On Wednesday, when Wilson had to get the big outs in the eighth inning, he did.

On Thursday, not so much.

Bookmark and Share
14 Comments to “New York, New York: Yankees Win Two Of Three After Rangers Fail To Make Early Lead Stand Up”
  • Bob Bland

    This could be one of those “catastrophic moment” games, should the season take a turn for the worse. Very poor outing by McCarthy, and Wash was foolish to run C.J. back out there again mere hours after his multi-inning dominance the night before.

  • jcouch

    stop knee jerking ppl…

  • Scott

    cj should not have been in. shouldve been your lefty specialist for the first two batters. If you cant count on eddie to get lefties out late in games, then you need to release him

  • FirebatM3

    Statement games are dumb, and I think people who believe in them might very well be dumber.

    This team made a “statement game” sweep of the Angels only to get swept in Detroit. This team lost 2 of 3 to New York only to take 3 of 4 from rival Oakland. It swept Cleveland only to drop 7 of their next ten.

    There are no such things as statement games. There are only games you lose and those you loss. Momentum simply depends on tomorrow’s starter.

  • haiku man

    CJ overused
    Cabrera gets a cheapie
    Evan not too harsh

  • Sriram

    I’m not sure I agree with not bringing CJ into this situation – but I do agree that if you’re not going to bring in your LOOGY (Guardado) to face two LHBs in the top of the 8th, then he’s just taking up roster space and needs to be released.

  • Russ

    Seems like 90% of the losses, people blame on Wash. I agree with the sentiment regarding Guardado, but people think because CJ pitched yesterday, that was the reason for the bad pitch(as he called it) to Cabrera, then that is just not true.

    Look around MLB, 8th inning pitchers go several days in a row, just like Closers do. CJ threw about 25 pitches on Wednesday, if that is to many pitches, where he can not pitch the next day, then this team needs 2 8th inning, “setup” men, since yall dont want CJ to throw 2 days in a row.

  • Scott

    I’m not blaming Wash at all. I’m looking at a very weak bullpen for a team that is contending!

    I like CJ, Frankie, and Oday…but is that enough????

  • David C

    I don’t get the idea that it was imperative to have Guardado in at that point. You say if Eddie can’t get lefthanders out he should be released…well if CJ can throw two days in a row maybe he should be released. It was the 8th inning. That has now become Wilson’s part of the game, so he was right where he needed to be.

    And I don’t know about catastrophic moments, but I do fully expect three losses this weekend. I would have said that had the Rangers won yesterday, by the way. I am just hoping they can get through NY and Boston and still have a two game lead.

  • Jericho

    CJ is one of those guys who is a lightning rod. I personally like the guy despite the fact I get nervous EVERYTIME he enters a game. However,he has great stuff, a live arm, and guts. People are entitled to their opinion on him, but if he were to get traded we would be sorry. I do not hear this comparison much these days, but he reminds me of Mitch “Wild Thing” Williams. I would rather have him in the bunker than be fighting him.

  • Scott

    @ David C I think the 8th inning role should be used when you have a lead, not tied.

    In the situation yesterday, I would’ve preferred eddie to pitch to the lefties and then Oday for the rest of the 8th and 9th unless you take the lead, then you go to Frankie.

    I think the rangers tee off on Penny tonite and Millwood “holds” boston to 5 in 7 and rangers win…then lose next two

  • David C

    Fair enough.

  • Friday morning Rangers things

    [...] Evan Grant’s game story highlights that point…he talks about Melky Cabrera’s game-winning homer being just barely too far for David Murphy to snag (and a ball that likely is a flyout anyway in most parks), and compares the Michael Young-started double play that got Scott Feldman out of a bases loaded jam on Wednesday to the almost-identical ball that Mark Teixeira hit yesterday that went for a three run double and tied up the game.  [...]

  • JustSaying

    Young just didn’t make the play…….and it was ugly…..